Whether you treat your skin with an acne gel, acne cream, acne foam, or acne lotion is not as important as the ingredients the product contains. For some skin care problems, however, lotions are best.
We’ve done the research for you…
- There is nothing special about a product for acne just because it is a lotion, a gel, a foam, or a wash. What counts is what’s used to make the product, the right ingredients in the right amount at the right pH.
- Never put anything that feels thick or heavy on your face if you have acne. If it feels heavy, it is probably blocking pores.
- Many lotions for acne contain additional ingredients that can harm your skin.
- Alcohol and plant essences can increase oil production instead of reducing it.
- Probably the best way to find the right acne lotion is to start with a skin care system, such as Exposed Skin Care.
What Is a Lotion?
A lotion is nothing more than a liquid product that is thin enough to be spread over the skin easily and thick enough to stay on the skin for minutes or hours until it is washed off or dissolves in perspiration. Usually lotions have very small bubbles or no bubbles at all, and they are used to provide substances for the skin rather to remove dirt, grime, or oil off the skin.
Most lotions contain both water and at least one ingredient that is not readily soluble in water. To make sure the active ingredients stay dispersed, and don’t precipitate down the bottom of the container, most lotions contain one or more surfactants or slipping agents to keep the ingredients mixed. These additives can cause problems in some products.
Lotions: Good, Bad, and Ugly
A good acne lotion is one that delivers:
- A skin healing ingredient,
- In the right concentration,
- At the right pH,
- In a liquid that stays on the skin long enough for the ingredient to do its job.
Many lotions have the wrong ingredient for a particular skin type. Or they might have the right ingredient in a concentration that is not strong enough to make a difference. Or they might be high-pH, alkaline formulas that don’t interact well with the skin. (Alkalizing is good inside the body, but mild acidifying is best for the skin.) Or the instructions with the product might say to wash it off after just a few minutes, soon enough to make absolutely sure no one writes in to complain about side effects, but not long enough to make a real difference for the skin.
There are a few lotions that are just plain harmful for blemished skin. The main problem areas are:
- Addition of alcohol and/or menthol to make the skin feel tingly. That “action” on the skin is the process of inflammation, not the process of healing.
- Use of sodium lauryl sulfate (the European spelling is “sulphate”) as a slipping agent. Women tend to be especially sensitive to this ingredient that can dry out the skin.
- Addition of fragrances, perfumes, and “natural ingredients” of dubious value to acne care but of considerable certainty of causing allergies.
If you have acne, it’s also important to avoid any lotion, cream, gel, or balm that feels thick on your skin. Any product you use should feel light. Thick lotions clog pores and, whatever potential benefit they may have for other skin problems, they make acne worse.
Now let’s take a look at some of the top selling brands among acne lotions.
Alpha Hydroxy Spot Light Targeted Skin Lightener
Here is a product retailing for US $9.99 that can be good, bad, or ugly, depending on the skin type of the person using it. Many times pimples heal and leave brown spots behind. Many people use lotions that contain hydroquinone to lighten the lingering discoloration.
Alpha Hydroxy Spot Light Targeted Skin Lightener contains not just one but two different ingredients that will get rid of brown (although not red or pink) discoloration on the skin, hydroquinone, which is a skin lightener, and glycolic acid, which is an alpha hydroxy acid used as a skin peel. Both of these ingredients are just fine if you have fair, dry skin. Either of these ingredients can be disastrous, causing even worse, permanent spotting, if you have Asian, Hispanic, or African skin tones. At just US $9.99 a jar, it is tempting to try it—but don’t, unless you have dry skin and fair skin tones with little gold or brown in your skin.
Alpha Hydroxy Enhanced Lotion 10% Glycolic Acid AHA
For US $2 more per container (and a lot less per application, since this buys you 6 times as much product) another product by the same company lightens acne-affected skin without risk of leaving permanent marks on skin with Asian, Hispanic, or African skin tones. Containing 10% glycolic acid, this acne lotion will both remove brown spots and help prevent the formation of new blackheads and whiteheads by keeping skin looser, giving it a healthy glow that isn’t due to chemical irritation! This product is still just for normal to dry skin (oily skin requires BHAs, not AHAs), but it is a good way to treat brown spots without risk of creating black or blue spots.
American Beauty All Is Forgiven Skin Repair Concentrate
Here is a lotion that really doesn’t do anything to repair damage from acne or any other skin problem, but that does leave skin looking nice. The mica and titanium dioxide give skin a healthy glow. It may be a little too “white” for dark skin tones.
Aveeno Continuous Radiance Moisturizing Lotion, For All Skin Tones
Here is a moisturizer that will indeed work with all skin tones. What the manufacturer does not tell you is that the sun tanning agent in the lotion will change any skin tone to a shade of orange.
Avon Mark Skin Care Need a Shrink? Pore Minimizer
This cleverly named product does not actually shrink enlarged pores left behind after blackheads are removed. What it does is to give an even finish to the skin so pores are not as noticeable.
Darphin Paris Skin Bronze Self-Tanning Face & Body Tinted Cream Lotion
Even if you have acne, you may want a nice summer (or even winter) tan. Darkening the skin, after all, helps conceal blemishes. Here is a lotion that is a great example of how paying more does not necessarily get you more. This product retails for US $50 for 4.2 ounces/135 g. It contains the exact same ingredients as products that cost $10, plus eugenol, linalool, and mint, which dry out and irritate the skin—especially fair skin, the skin type to which the product is most frequently applied.
In choosing any tanning lotion, it is important to remember that the darker the tan, the more likely the product is to create streaks or blotches on your skin.
Shiseido Pureness Anti-Shine Refreshing Lotion
Here is a product advertised for people who have blemish-prone, acne-prone oily skin. It contains the beta-hydroxy acid that people with oily skin need to help keep pores open. Unfortunately, it contains only a small amount of beta-hydroxy acids at a pH that is so high they will not have any effect on the skin. And because the product contains alcohol to give the skin a tingly feeling, it actually increases sebum production while not doing very much to reduce excess sebum that may already be present.
Trish McEvoy Gentle Cleansing Lotion
At US $58 for 6.2 ounces/187 ml, this product delivers the gentle cleansing it promises for blemished, dry, and fair skin. It contains no ingredients that harm the skin. Neither does Neutrogena, for about $50 less.
Related acne articles:
- Can a Book Help Cure Your Acne? Writers of acne books often promise overnight cures of skin care issues you have had for weeks, months, or years. No acne book can tell...
- Could a Colon Cleanse Really Cure Acne? Can a colon cleanse clear up acne? Unless you somehow managed to get acne in your colon, the answer is no, but colon health actually...
- How to Use Foundation Powders to Hide Acne Foundation makeup can make acne worse, or help clear up blemished skin for good. It’s all in how you use it. This article explains what...
- Is Brown Skin Much more Prone to Acne? When acne occurs on brown skin, special handling is required. People who have brown skin tend to get acne later in life, and sometimes don’t...
- How to Cure Acne – Taking a Look at Natural Cures for Acne Can you really cure acne and get rid of unsightly blemishes and pimples for good? Almost every acne sufferer can cure acne with a minimum...