Last Updated on January 6th, 2020
We all know that acne just isn’t fair. It messes up your skin. It can ruin your social life and bring your romantic life to a halt.
And acne experts are always telling us that “if it tastes good, you probably can’t eat it,” if you have acne. Now a study conducted by scientists in Malaysia concludes that, especially for people who have Asian skin types, ice cream aggravates acne.
What’s the issue with ice cream for people who have acne?
The problem with ice cream for acne seems to be its contribution to a dietary measurement known as glycemic load, rather than just a problem with milk fat. In other words, low-fat ice cream is just as problematic as the “good stuff.” And there is a hormone in most dairy products that activates the production of pimples, although there is one form of dairy that is safe for acne sufferers.
Article Table of Contents
Before about 1970, every acne sufferer used to be told that the key to a clear face was just to avoid consuming soft drinks, any kind of chocolate, any kind of nuts or peanuts, and all fried foods. (As hard as it may be to believe, fried foods, due to lingering food shortages, were considered a luxury at the time, and many people seldom ate them.) When skin care researchers did careful testing of the effects of these products on real-world acne sufferers, however, they found that, for the most part, carbonated beverages, chocolate, peanuts and tree nuts, and even fried foods high in saturated fat had no consistent effect on acne.
Instead, a series of research findings from around the world began to point to dairy products as a trigger for acne outbreaks.
What is it about cow’s milk that makes skin break out? Most cow’s milk products are high in a naturally occurring hormone called insulin-like growth factor-1, abbreviated IGF-1. This is not a hormone that is artificially added to milk or that is injected into cows. It’s a natural growth factor that the mother cow provides her baby calf that stimulates cell growth. After all, if you are a calf, and you need to grow into a cow, stimulating cell division is an unabashedly good thing.
But if you are a teenager or adult dealing with acne, hormones from milk are just about the last thing you need. The same IGF-1 that helps a calf develop into a cow stimulates the growth of skin cells in the lining of pores, and it can induce sebum production as well. The neck of pores in the skin in the face, neck, and trunk gets clogged, acne bacteria accumulate, the immune system tries to remove them, and pimples result.
Studies in South Korea and Malaysia, dealing with acne sufferers who have Asian skin types, have found that there is a clear relationship between the consumption of milk, especially of ice cream, and the development of acne. Studies of acne sufferers in the USA, which were not limited to any particular skin type, found that women who drink 2 or more servings of skim milk per day (from which fat would not be a problem) were 22% more likely to develop acne vulgaris, the common form of acne, and 44% more likely to develop cystic acne, the form of acne that is extremely difficult to treat. But one other aspect of diet can make the problem even worse.
Most dairy products aggravate acne because they contain an “insulin-like” growth factor. But the pore-clogging effects of the insulin-like hormone on the skin are augmented by the insulin produced by the body.
Unless you have type 1 diabetes, your body makes insulin that moves sugar out of the bloodstream and into every cell in the body for use as fuel. The pancreas releases insulin in pulses timed to keep blood glucose levels more or less constant. Most of the time, it stores insulin into tiny packets. About 90 minutes after you eat (specifically, when your gut begins to expand with the digested food released from your stomach), the insulin-producing cells of the pancreas break open those packets to release a surge of insulin into your bloodstream to move the digested sugars where they need to go.
As a side effect, the temporary surge in insulin produces a temporary surge in the product of skin cells in pores. The more insulin your pancreas releases, the more acne is stimulated. But the more sugar you consume, the more insulin is poured into your bloodstream.
Ice cream doesn’t just provide the insulin-like growth factor-1, it also stimulates the body to produce actual insulin. Ice cream, three studies have confirmed, aggravates acne through not just but two hormonal processes. The more sugary foods you eat, the more insulin your body has to make, the more your pores are stimulated in ways that leave them clogged.
All of this makes ice cream a no-no for acne sufferers. But you don’t necessarily have to give up all your frozen dairy desserts. Frozen yogurt is still OK (but sugar-sweetened non-dairy desserts such as sherbets and sorbets also add to glycemic load, thus stimulating insulin production and aggravating acne.
The process of making yogurt breaks down the insulin-like growth factor-1 that is found in milk. And because the process of making yogurt also converts some of the naturally occurring sugars in milk into lactic acid, yogurt is digested more slowly. The more slowly your stomach releases digested food into your small intestine, the less insulin the pancreas releases into your bloodstream, and the less your pores are stimulated to clog.
Ice cream isn’t poisonous. A little bit now and then, even if it’s chocolate, isn’t likely to cause you to break out. But if you just have to have a frozen dessert every day, make it frozen yogurt rather than ice cream.